Monday, May 17, 2010

Suicide is Painless

Before I even begin, let me start by saying that this post will probably not be a popular one. It deals with a sensitive subject and my not-so-sensitive opinion about it, so be forewarned.

Secondly, I had an epiphany this morning that is totally unrelated, but I believe that the BS skills I learned in my HS English classes will come in handy and allow me to somehow weave it into this post. Have faith.

On Thursday, I was informed that our little theatre community had lost yet another talented individual to death. The unofficial news spread just as quickly that his death was a suicide. The sad thing... no one I spoke to about it seemed at all surprised. "He was troubled," they say. "He was dealing with demons," people explain. And the ultimate caveat... "Tortured artist."

In May of 2008, a writer friend of mine committed suicide after losing his job at a flailing local newspaper and running into problems stemming from a repeated DUI offense. I heard the same explanations at the time. "He was a self-imposed perfectionist suffering from his inner demons." "He was troubled." ..."Tortured writer."

I never met my maternal grandfather. He was a 'troubled man' who was 'dealing with inner demons' and so he 'chose to end his life' when my mother and her sister were still just kids. He was a decorated war hero, a pilot in the Air Force, that had flown several high-profile missions against nazi targets in southern Europe. A painted portrait of him hung in our house and it used to creep me out as a kid. He left a suicide note in a Sun Pontiac envelope and his legacy (in my life) is no more than a collection of amazing photos from his days flying a B-24 Liberator. His name wasn't often mentioned in our house.

I have countless friends whose lives have been altered and devastated by suicide... and the events of the past week have had me humming the theme song to MASH in that tragically ironic way as I contemplate the ways in which suicide is in no way painless.

In the case of the friend who passed two years ago this month, he left an entire theatre and journalism community stunned and confused. This was no emo fellah sporting a 'woe is me' attitude and guyliner. He was just an average American Joe with problems.

In the case of the fellow artist who passed this week, he leaves behind a devastated mother (who has just lost her 28-year-old son) and a myriad associates and co-artists who have at some point been either infuriated or inspired by him. He was young. So young. And he had problems.

My grandfather... may have committed suicide to save himself the trouble of facing consequences for poor decisions during and after his military career. It's possible someone else may have done the job for him had he not made the swift decision himself. He was an emotionally unstable veteran with problems.

I'm angry with them. And it's not fair. I want to be able to mourn them properly and grieve and celebrate their presence and influence in my life, but I'm prevented by the anger and confusion that I feel.

Suicide is cowardly. It is selfish.

I will admit that on more than one occasion, I've fantasized about falling asleep to never wake up. I've had those 'to be or not to be' moments with myself when I felt like my responsibilities and obstacles were insurmountable. But I was just incapable of being that selfish. And don't get me wrong... I'm selfish. I'm one of the most selfish people I know. But I can't turn off that part of me that considers the pain and anguish of those I'd leave behind.

Maybe I'm just a narcissist and place too much importance on my role in other people's lives, but I can't reconcile being the cause of someone's pain. Especially someone I care about.

Furthermore, the whole concept of suicide (to me) means that you've figured it all out for yourself. There's nothing left to learn, nothing remarkable worth experiencing. I know people that have lived very full lives at 100 that indicate they are still learning new things every day.

We all have problems and we all have issues. And though we compare and quantify who 'has it better' or who 'has it worse' than we do, the truth of the matter is that the human condition is more similar than we acknowledge. Your worst day and my worst day might not have anything more in common except for the fact that they were our 'worst days' and we felt the same depth of extreme emotion... sadness, fear, anxiety, despair. Your best day and my best day can still be factored down to the lowest common denominator of euphoria, joy, victory.

The complex emotions we feel and our ability to express them creatively is what makes us human - much more so than our ability to use tools and develop intricate civilizations. (In my opinion.) Our art... our expression... is so vital to our existence. Though not always pleasant.

And speaking of art... My epiphany this morning was not an anticipated one.
I accidentally clicked on a photo of one of those 3-D art things. You know... the picture that looks nothing more like a bunch of colored dots all over the page. You're supposed to stare at it until you 'see' the picture take shape right in front of your disbelieving eyes.
Well, until this morning, I was starting to believe that they were all a bunch of hogwash. I'd never ever ever been successful and I've made a downright fool of myself in local malls trying.

Until this morning.

I started thinking about art and what it says and whether or not a bunch of dots on a page could be considered art... when I found myself staring into space (aka my monitor) and an honest-to-goodness horse appeared. With a broken picket fence behind it. Holy crap!

And to think that I had almost completely given up on ever understanding or appreciating that kind of art. You see, new things to learn and experience every day. Even on accident.

And so it is with mixed feelings that I write this... knowing that another voice has been silenced. One that was tortured by the dark side of this emotional existence, but will no longer express it through any medium save for the art he leaves behind.

It makes me angry.
It makes me sad.
It makes me grateful that I am made of 'sterner stuff'.
So far... nothing has been unbearable.
And so I count my blessings and hope that they have each found peace on the other side.














Noah Todd as Osric

SWShakespeare's Hamlet (Photo: Laura Durant)





Chris Page
Writer, Critic, Musician, General Funny-Man
















Col. Earl Osborne
Husband, father, commander

20 comments:

  1. You are an idiot.

    How do you think Noah's mother is going to feel if she reads this, seeing you calling Noah a 'coward' and 'selfish'.

    How dare you think that you have the right to feel angered by what happened.

    By the way, no one that really knows him told you that he was troubled or dealing with Daemons. He was not a tortured artist.

    This all happened over a girl.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Suicide is selfish. You think only about yourself and your escape and not what you do and how it will affect others. And if you are correct and this was all over a girl, that's just really sad. No one should define their life, let alone choose to selfishly end it, because of someone else.

    ReplyDelete
  3. 1.) I never claimed to be smart.
    2.) This is not a blog about Noah. It's about suicide. He was one of three examples given, one of which is my own grandfather. I have a right to feel however the hell I want about whatever the hell I want. Including suicide, politics and abortion. Step off.
    3.) I doubt Noah's mom would read my blog. If she did, I hope she'd know that my sincerest condolences are with her and all of Noah's close friends and family (of which I am not). As a parent, I'd be angry if my son chose to end his life. I'd be even more angry if he chose to do it over a girl. Seriously? You think that's a consolation?

    It's easy to pretend you're a big smarty smarterson when you're behind your anonymous computer there, Charlie. Think before you knee-jerk react next time. And if you don't like it, then don't fucking read it. It ain't your blog. It's mine. :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi,
      Even though your article brings up valid points and I can feel your sincerity and passion behind your words I have to totally disagree.

      I think a lot of what you are saying is obviously very subjective and your own past has a lot to do with the way you view suicide.
      That said, I obviously do no condone suicide yet as a long time sufferer of depression I can tell you that there is nothing 'selfish' about suicide...

      Have you thought about what kind of lives people lead when they are severely depressed? How that life in itself causes a tremendous amount of suffering to said person's family and friends?
      This is something I think you have forgotten to think about. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying that suicide brought happiness to the friends and family of the victim but you may be surprised at the amount of times it at least brought closure to a CONSTANT battle.

      Argh.. I feel like I am not expressing myself properly.. All I am trying to say is calling suicide 'selfish' is insulting to me. It is not an easy way out, it simply feels like the ONLY way out.

      Things can obviously change and I hate it when I hear about a case which could have obviously been prevented if a proper support system was in place, I cannot imagine a lonelier moment than the second before the trigger is pulled (or whatever it may be).
      It brings tears to my eyes just thinking about that decisive moment, that moment of clarity among the chaos where the person completely loses the will to go on, it truly does...

      But I personally will never call suicide selfish simply because that demeans not only your opinion of a particular victim but all victims of suicide.. It is not something people take lightly (again there are exceptions to the rule, mostly teenagers or young adults who are simply lost briefly) and to call it 'selfish' is an assumption (I feel) on your part, as if to say all these people have not thought about the consequence of their action and they are merely leaving the country on holiday to a secluded island no one is allowed to go to apart from them.

      I hope I am being coherent, and somehow getting a different perspective across, I am also sorry for your personal losses which I cannot understand like you can.

      Here is a decent analogy I just thought of which might help get my personal view across. The victim's life is like a life sentence in prison, now when you are a parent to the victim and you know you have lost the ability to touch and connect with your child(metaphorically speaking) and he/she has given up and wants to be free. would it not be selfish to keep them around for your own personal reasons (missing them / needing them)

      All I am trying to say is that calling suicide selfish is a completely one sided view and suicide is often much more complex.
      Again, to reiterate I don't condone suicide I merely think it is too simply to dismiss it as 'selfish'.

      Anyways, great article I just happened onto it by chance while looking into Noah Todd's passing after finishing "the Prometheus project" where he was commemorated in the credits.

      ps: here is what seemed to be a great documentary about suicide ( I could not watch more than half as I found it gut wrenchingly depressing ) but it may help get some different views on suicide, it is called "The Bridge" released in 2006 by director Eric Steel.

      Delete
  4. I was about to respond to the asshole who somehow thinks he/she has the right to dictate how you feel, but you seem to have done a pretty good job of it already.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Yeah, Andi... this is your blog, and you have every right to say what you are feeling. I think this is a great blog post. Don't let anonymous snipers who spell it "daemons" get to you.

    ReplyDelete
  6. It was not a suicide you ass. He was not in any ANY way suicidal.

    A Close Friend of Noah.

    ReplyDelete
  7. This post was initially in response to the reports circulating around UofA the morning after. You're a little late, but whatev. So perhaps you'll share with the rest of the class what really happened...and EDUCATE us. Or perhaps you'll hide behind an anonymous moniker to call people names. Regardless, the attitudes behind the responses of Noah's 'close friends' leave little doubt what kind of people he surrounded himself with. So much love and kindness... I'm choking on it.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I fell upon your blog by chance. I was extremely angry at what I saw. I don't know if I want to apologize as I feel that the justification you give for your statements which rely idyll rumors is senseless crap.

    Feel as you want, just do not use others for your "outlets".

    I am choking on the crap you write. Educate yourself by reading instead of assumptions kid.


    Kirsten

    ReplyDelete
  9. Kirsten,
    I don't know that I gave any justifications for my statements, but I will.
    First, I have yet to hear from a reliable source of what actually happened that ill-fated night. Since you don't specify, I'll assume that your negative response is in seeing this blog as it relates to Noah and the controversy surrounding his passing.
    Since hearing that he had passed (and in the same sentence, hearing that it was suicide) I have since heard that it was a) something related to a girl b) that it was self-inflicted, but accidental and c) that it was a homicide. Because all of these statements came in anonymously, I have to treat them as the same 'idyll' rumors, don't I?

    It was never my intention to use anyone as an 'outlet'. As I've said before, my post was on suicide and I used the three examples I did to try to relate as a survivor, friend and parent of one who has been lost to us by their own hand. I do acknowledge that there has been a vehement response in regard to my including Noah, but I'm unsure why... other than the general response that I'm an ass spewing crap.
    Thanks for clearing that up.
    I'm not sure what led you to my blog or what exactly made you angry, but I respect your opinion and the courage to stand behind your words.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I have been wondering what happened to Noah since I first heard the news of his passing. I honestly can't imagine suicide would be his way out. All in all, I'm glad to have some closure to what has happened to him. The mystery of his death has been puzzling me over a year now. He was an amazing person to know. His mother is an amazing woman. My prayers are with her. I thank you for indirectly helping me discovered what happened in his passing. Just because suicide was his way out doesn't mean he was a coward. I do know Noah lost his father when he was young and that depression can drive a person not to think rationally. Thank you for some closure.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Does anyone know the cause of death??

    BTW, more power to you dramamama, you stated it was just a rumor, you're not in the wrong.

    ReplyDelete
  12. by gunshot, and there was no gun found at the scene. You tell me?

    ReplyDelete
  13. So, why is no one talking? Demanding answers? Is there an active investigation? This post still gets a lot of hits - 2 years later - which leads me to believe there are still unanswered questions...

    ReplyDelete
  14. It was ruled an accident, it was a gun shot to the head...I rushed to his house as soon as I heard, and spoke to the detective assigned to the case...There was no evidence of a break in and there was a gun found on the scene. I grew up with Noah and he was faaaaaaaaaar from a coward. One of the toughest guys I've ever met...I knew him for 17 years...as well as his dad and mom...I miss him very much...but it wasn't a suicide...

    ReplyDelete
  15. Suicide *is* selfish... but then again, every act a person takes is selfish to some degree. Even the person who stops to help someone out of a bad situation reaps the benefits of feeling better from a small act of kindness.
    Suicide is not an act of cowardice.
    I just watched and enjoyed The Frankenstein Syndrome and was saddened to note the tribute to Noah at the credits end. Didn't know him personally and don't know what his gifts were, but obvious to me had a true talent for acting.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Steve is that you?........This has to be a homicide. Why aren't police investigating?

    ReplyDelete
  17. AZDramaMama, I'm truly sorry about your grandfather. But I think your comments were very well put. I can see how some people would be sensitive to what you said, but I, for one, think you did it with great dignity and honesty. I worked with Noah on his last film and feel no anger about his choice, only sadness. But again, I think your words were spot on. Kudos.

    ReplyDelete
  18. AZDramaMama, Thank you for your honest post. I have had 3 deaths in my family by suicide and it IS one of the most selfish AND cowardly acts that anyone can commit. Did I love these individuals? Absolutely! Were they "strong" individuals? Absolutely! Were the cowards? No! But the act they committed was!
    In each case, the person is in great pain and possibly dealing with "demons" and/or mental illness. There are numerous, less hurtful ways to get REAL help and deliverance-everywhere, especially for those who KNOW they are loved, but in the end the pain was just too great.
    My problem with this is that when an individual chooses suicide, it is not just a choice that they are making for themselves to escape the pain, but they TAKE AWAY the choice of those they leave behind, by transferring their pain to us, which we then have to suffer with for the rest of our lives. In them escaping their pain, it doesn't remove it-it multiplies it many times over, forever changing the lives of those they leave behind!
    As far as Noah's death being a homicide or suicide: the police and detectives are not stupid! If there was ANY doubt, there would have been an investigation, and quite possibly there was. Wake up, people! It may be hard for you to believe that he would have ever done such a thing, but you were not in his head, nor were you in his presence at the time of his death. Your "opinions" are based on gossip, not fact.

    ReplyDelete